Senator Wants Smithsonian Records on $50 Million Gift
By Jacqueline Trescott
Washington Post Staff Writer
Tuesday, May 4, 2004; Page C08
The chairman of the Senate Finance Committee yesterday publicly
asked the Smithsonian for all documents related to a gift of rare
musical instruments from Herbert Axelrod, a New Jersey businessman who
has fled to Cuba after being indicted for tax evasion.
Sen. Charles E. Grassley (R-Iowa) said he wanted to see any papers
related to the gift in 1998 of four Stradivarius musical instruments. At
the time of the donation, they were said to be worth $50 million, though
that figure has been questioned. The committee is investigating in-kind
gifts to charities and the tax implications.
"It is troubling that the Smithsonian may be turning a blind eye
to tax mischief. Government agencies should be working in concert, not
against each other. . . . Donors shouldn't be able to get away with
playing the taxpayers like a fiddle," said Grassley, in a statement
released yesterday.
Late last week the senator wrote Lawrence M. Small, the
Smithsonian secretary, to request for all materials related to the
donation. Grassley also asked to review all donations of more than $10
million received by the Smithsonian since Jan. 1, 2001.
Officials at the Smithsonian said they were cooperating with the
request.
Small, at a briefing for reporters after the quarterly meeting of
the Smithsonian Board of Regents, said the Smithsonian didn't do any
appraisal of the donations, which Axelrod claimed were worth $50
million.
"It is not the responsibility of any museum to do any appraising
or tax evaluation," said Small. "We do not know what any donor does in
the way of tax deductions at all. That is not our business. There is no
role that we play in that. We accept the gift. In some cases we will
acknowledge that we received the gift, but appraising is something that
has to be done by certified appraisers."
Axelrod, 76, has been charged with trying to defraud the Internal
Revenue Service by helping a former employee hide $700,000 in bonuses in
a Swiss bank account. That charge has also brought into question his
sale to the New Jersey Symphony Orchestra of 30 stringed instruments.
The selling price was $18 million, but Axelrod had valued the
instruments at $50 million.
Small said yesterday that the gift agreement with the Smithsonian
did not mention a dollar value.
Axelrod made his fortune by publishing pet books. His lawyer has
said he has not broken any laws.
Small said he was "quite amazed" by the revelations about Axelrod.
"He is someone whose relationship with the Smithsonian goes back 40
years, so I was quite surprised to read what I read," said Small. He
added that the Smithsonian hasn't been drawn directly into the broader
tax evasion case. "Whatever his personal case is . . . as far as I know
[it doesn't have] anything to do with us."
Since 1994, Axelrod donated cash gifts to the Smithsonian totaling
$2.8 million. The money went to the National Museum of Natural History
and the National Museum of American History, including funding for
performances, exhibitions and maintenance of the donated instruments --
two violins, a viola and a cello. The instruments were on loan to
American History for 12 years before the 1998 donation.
In other Smithsonian news, Small said that strong sales at the
gift shops and Imax theaters indicated that visits to all the museums
were increasing. In the first quarter of 2004, Small said the sales were
up around 25 percent. "That's substantially better than last year," he
said.
However, better counting methods of visitors produced a decrease
in the number of visits compared with the same period a year earlier.
"Statistically our visitation is down slightly from last year,
about 16 percent," said Small. "We don't think that reflects what is
really going on on the Mall."
He attributed the variation to improvement in the way visitors are
counted, partly as a result of new security methods. For instance, now
staffers aren't counted as visitors because they have identification
that allows them to bypass the electronic screening.
The Udvar-Hazy Center, the Dulles Airport adjunct to the National
Air and Space Museum, continues to be a popular destination. It received
835,000 visitors since it opened in mid-December, making it the fourth
most visited Smithsonian attraction, after, in order, the Air and Space
Museum (on the Mall), Natural History and American History.